Supplies You'll Need for Aging Paper A piece of paper you want to age. Burn Paper. I saw Martha "antique" paper a few years ago, and although I don’t remember her technique, I do remember that it was complicated. 1.Using the foam roller, apply varnish to a clean, lightly sanded surface. I played around with the general idea, though, and came up with an easy way to get the same aged look. The easiest way to age wood is with things you probably already have in your kitchen.Pour vinegar into the glass jar, filling it about halfway. You can also use it to make a birthday party invitation look fancy. Now, take a match and hold it right under the paper. Follow by keeping the paper in an oven for about four minutes. (I used regular 24lb laser paper. The act of making your normal paper appear old is one easy way you can add some more fun to new creative projects and avoid the high cost of getting the real thing. The look, feel and smell of an old paper can make you think of the olden days papers like the Celtic parchment, the Papyrus of Egypt and the ancient Rice Paper of China. You can make paper look old with coffee, or you can tea stain paper BUT this is the fast and easy method to make paper look old with an antiquing glaze. There are … Burn the paper to make it look old. Tie with a leather string or old brown string to make it really resemble a scroll-like letter. Now you've got your parchment paper like they used in the early 1400's. Hold the paper on top of a candle flame. Using the high quality paint brush, lay off the varnish in the direction of the grain. 2.When 1st step is dry, prepare your glaze by making a mixture of TB colorant by a 1:6 ratio with glaze. Shred the steel wool and add it to the jar. Keep the lighted match under the paper, till the time you get the burnt look. Age Paper to Make it Look Old the Easy Way. Use a fountain pen to write with to make the parchment look old. How to Age Paper to Make it Look Old the Easy Way. Next, dampen the paper a bit.